One topic that generates a lot of discussion is the transition from analogue to IP cameras.
On new construction, it’s rapidly becoming a moot point — there are so many advantages to IP, and the cost advantage of analogue is rapidly disappearing — but there are a lot of analogue systems out there that are aging out.
In those cases, we often hear that people don’t want to replace the wiring and that it’s simpler to plug in a new analogue camera than go through the pain of conversion.
That pain of conversion is rapidly becoming less and less painful.
How to use an analogue fibre-optic converter
If you haven’t looked at the various media converters on the market, you’ll be pleasantly surprised.
What started as a niche product for smaller manufacturers has rapidly hit the mainstream, and there are so many types of products out there that it’s hard to find an application that isn’t already well served.
Ethernet fibre-optic media converters started the trend.
These were initially very pricey in the security industry but as people discovered that they were available in the IT industry for a third of the cost, security manufacturers came to their senses.
They are simple to use: Unplug the analogue fibre-optic modules, plug in the Ethernet media converters, and you’re up and running.
Some tips: Buy gigabit converters as they don’t cost much more and turn every fibre line into a backbone.
At the device end, they need to be standalone units, but at the closet or head end you can use GBIC cards that plug into that port on your network switch if you’ve done your homework and bought switches with GBIC slots.
And don’t go with the units that take a single fibre but cost more unless you have to.
Since you have tremendous bandwidth with these modules, go ahead and use a dual fibre module if you have the strands available.
Remember, you can send hundreds of cameras over two strands of fibre, so if you’re replacing analogue modules with these converters you’ll have plenty of fibre left over.
Coaxial media converters
Coaxial media converters came next, and we are seeing more and more of them.
They are sold in pairs, and again, they’re pretty simple. Unplug each end of the coax, plug a module on each end, and you have an Ethernet connection.
Your speed will vary based on distance and the quality of the cable, but for a single camera or two, these work just fine.
Some tips: You get what you pay for, and the less expensive units don’t hold up.
Believe it or not, bigger is often better, as the physically smaller units seem to have less surge protection and poorer heat dissipation, contributing to early failure.
That being said, we expect these to continue to get better and cheaper, making the case for conversion even simpler.
Ethernet extenders
If you have one of those applications that used unshielded twisted pair (UTP) cabling thinking it would make you future-proof, only to discover that your cable runs are all over the 100 meter limit for Ethernet, do not despair.
A variation of the coaxial media converter is the Ethernet extender; same principal, and often the same product in a different package.
Some tips: Just because you’re going over CAT5 cable doesn’t mean you have unlimited bandwidth — these units are not backbone worthy and are made for a few cameras, not an IDF closet.
The right cable
Again, there are a lot of flimsy and fragile products out there, so go with a brand, reputation, and warranty you can trust.
Media converters are a valuable addition to any tool kit, but they aren’t a substitute for running the right cable in the first place.
Remember the old adage: When the only tool you have is a hammer, pretty soon everything looks like a nail.
That being said, there are times when only a hammer will do!
Free Download: The Video Surveillance Report 2023
Discover the latest developments in the rapidly-evolving video surveillance sector by downloading the 2023 Video Surveillance Report. Over 500 responses to our survey, which come from integrators to consultants and heads of security, inform our analysis of the latest trends including AI, the state of the video surveillance market, uptake of the cloud, and the wider economic and geopolitical events impacting the sector!
Download for FREE to discover top industry insight around the latest innovations in video surveillance systems.
There are many variants out there. one that was missed out above was Ethernet over twisted pair. This does the same as the coax version and will allow the signal to be transmitted over a much greater distances than standard Ethernet.
Sorry to say that but it is funny.
When we talk about fiber-optic we must use the American spelling for the word fiber, and when we talk about fibre-channel, which is SAN protocol we must use the British spelling for the word fibre in fibre-channel.
Little extra about fiber-optic light transmitters.
There are two types of light transmitters that are used with with fiber-optic.
The first one is LED transmitter which can be used only with multi-mode fiber-optic.
The second one is LASER transmitter which can be used with multi-mode fiber-optic and single-mode fiber-optic, because the light generated is coherent.
Little extra to add on UTP
The UTP types (cat 5, cat 5e, cat 6) can transmit the digital signal over only 100 m, but the difference is their electric characteristic that make cat 5e and cat 6 have wider frequency band that make the pulses less deformed when reaching the far end, and this means that we can send shorter duration pulses or in other words higher bit rate.
I covered unshielded twisted pair (UTP) calling it an “Ethernet media extender.” But, you are correct in that I really implied CAT5/CAT53/CAT6 cable in saying that, and there are many existing installations using telecom (CAT3 or lower). Thanks for pointing this out.
I absolutely agree. I had spelled it the correct way but alas, as I am an American, everything I write gets run through the UK spell checker. While (whilst?) I ordinarily don’t mind, in this case it did change the meaning a bit. Sorry!
Thank you for the additional information regarding fiber optic and Category rated cable. I have plans to cover these in a future blog entry. In particular, we run across clients that want to use CAT6 everywhere and there is a case that can be made for it being overkill and adding unnecessary cost in certain applications. Also, it isn’t CAT6 unless it’s CAT6 everywhere — patch panels, connectors, etc. As for fiber, there are questions about using single mode versus multi-mode. At one time we were specifying single mode everywhere for IP systems, but we see it going both ways… Read more »
Thank you for your comment.
I did not try to blame you for the spelling, I mentioned that because it is really funny to have these two names as the official ones and we must say I am using fibre-channel protocol over fiber-optic cable in SAN.
I think it will be very OK to mix cat 5 and cat 6 in the network by dedicating cat 5 only to cameras and cat 6 to the rest of the network.
Well said, it is really very helpfl guide about fiber optics & it’s related content. I am waiting for the blog for which you are going to plan. I am alwyas love to read the article which is related to fiber optics.
The TFC-2000S20 Fiber Converter meets expectations with the TFC-1000 undercarriage framework or as a standalone unit. This converter is a Single Mode SC-Type fiber converter traversing separations up to 20km (12.4 miles). Ports incorporate 1 x 1000Base-T (RJ-45) port and 1 x 1000Base-LX (SC-Type) port.
For more info: http://www.trendnet.com.au/index.php/fibre.html